You built mansions on the plains and hewed the hills into houses[7:74]. Ruins of Aad and Thamood existed at time of Prophet sallallaahu alayhi wa sallam Assalaamu alaykum I was wondering does verse 2938 of the Quran mean that the houses of Aad and Thamud are still standing and that we can see them If Aad were destroyed there is nothing left of Aad apart from their land so their houses have fallen down and if they were not standing in Prophet Muhammads sallallaahu . Instead, they tried to engage Salih in debate. Hence, they didnt engage in long, drawn out debates with Hud. We have no concrete evidence that Nabateans were destroyed. Compounding the confusion is the fact that the tribal name Thamud is applied today to a broad section of different peoples throughout history, not only to those mentioned in the Quran. [26] The Arab descendants of the original Arabian settlers who continue to speak Arabic as a first language currently form the single largest population group in North Africa. And you said the nabteons built over them so if they built over them all then how could the prophet see them or the quran describe them when they were built over by them and by the time the prophet came because the nabateans came before jazzakkallah, But these are the last 5 questions and thats it sorry to keep bothering you it is that Im getting all the information I can so if Im ever questioned then I can answer them jazzakkallah, Sorry just 2 more but thats it most of these questions are yes or no Do you construct on every elevation a sign amusing yourselves? I dont know and this is a good aspect of the Quran; it does not go into such things and instead instructs us to focus on the message and not the nitty gritty. Ad and Thamud were two great civilizations destroyed by God due to their excessive wickedness. Here is how their argument goes: The Quran describes prophet called Salih ( ), who lived in the Thamud tribe. Here is how their argument goes: The Quran describes prophet called Salih ( ), who lived in the Thamud tribe. And indeed (their destruction) is clearly apparent to you from their (ruined) dwellings. This structure is not only large enough to house several individuals, but contains benches which suggests that it served some social function, hence it can qualify to be called a place of dwelling. So you must also monitor your life for the signs that youre receiving. By declining the noun Thamud or not, it means the region or the tribe. There is a place called Khyber at Pakistan/Afghanistan border but that is NOT the Khyber of Madina. The Middle verse in chapter (11) of the New Testament says:" He that hath ears to hear, let him hear." The Middle verse in chapter (11) of the . These prefixes ignored in the alphabetical ordering: Al, Banu. Will you forbid us to worship what our fathers worshiped? Under the Umayyad Caliphate, Arabic became the official language in Egypt rather than Coptic or Greek. These verses can be found in multiple books, we will focus on Obadiah and Jeremiah. A Warning to the Disbelievers and a Reminder of the Story of `Ad and Thamud. Thus, if the Quran is in error about the identities of whoever carved out the structures in Madian Salehor wherever else the Thamud livedthe Bible is also in error when it claims a pre-Nabatean people carved out structures in the mountains of Edom. [13] Adnanites are believed to be the descendants of Ishmael through Adnan but the traditional Adnanite lineage doesn't match the biblical line exactly. While certain online Christian communities are abuzz with elation and glee, some Muslims are faced with difficulties in formulating a proper response to the latest Christian accusation. To Aad was sent the prophet Hud; to Thamud, Saleh, and together with another mysterious figure, Shoaib, they constitute the only three pre-Islamic prophets mentioned in the Quran that have an exclusive Arab provenance. We simply do not know the true date and timeline for when the first Thamud of the Quran existed and, therefore, it would be difficult, if not impossible, to accurately identify the ruins of such an ancient civilization that lived thousands years ago. But the Thamud cut its hamstring or otherwise wounded it. And perhaps, using the knowledge, culture, and technology from the Aad, they established a new society. It does not state, however, who made the inscriptions. Just leave her alone. And We saved those who believed and had Taqwa. As is the usual case, the Christians are, 1. The Thamd were known from contemporary sources to have occupied parts of the Hejaz region, and later Islamic tradition holds that they settled on the slopes of Mount Athlab. (LogOut/ However, inside most of them is only a small room about three to four square meters in size. Its like me living in a house, then someone tears it down and then builds another house and says Abdullah used to live in that house while the fact is that I did not. There is no good reason to suggest that these tombs never served as a place of dwelling, as they are large enough to do so. Here our discussion lies around the location of the thamud people and the houses/tombs they carved out of the stones and mountains. As for option 2, we know next to nothing about the Thamud. They didnt bluntly reject Salih like the Aad did to Hud. Vol. The tribes of Arabia descend from either one of the two Arab ancestors, Adnan or Qahtan. If not, then why do we need to find the remains of Thamud? But the shriek seized them at early morning. He replaced the people of the Flood with the Aad and then replaced the Aad with the Thamud. and make your nest among the stars, [18] According to the Quran, the Thamud were the successors of a previous nation called the d, who had also been destroyed for their sins. As their material wealth increased so, too, did their evil ways while their virtue decreased. But we can conclude from the verses of the Quran that they lived sometime after the flood of Noah and before the time of Ibrahim (AS). The tribes of Ad and Thamud were ancient people who existed on the Arabian Peninsula many centuries ago and were recipients of the Prophets Hud and Salih, respectively. [1] Arab tribes have historically inhabited the Arabian Peninsula, but after the spread of Islam, they began to heavily migrate and settle in other areas such as the Levant,[2] Mesopotamia,[3] Egypt,[4] Sudan,[5] the Maghreb,[6] and Khuzestan. In other words either the evidence no longer exists (no problem) or Thamudic dwellings in North West Arabia are. [3] Nigel Groom, Frankincense and Myrrh, A Study of the Arabian Incense Trade, Longman, London and New York; Librairie du Liban, Beirut, 1981, p. 189, pg. The Ayah is general [And how many a city have I (Allah) destroyed]? Theres no real reason to mention them lastly, except they came after al-Rass and they are also included in this chronological order as well. And remember when He made you successors after the Aad and settled you in the land?Chapter 7, Verse 74. They are mentioned in the Quran as examples of civilizations that Allah had destroyed because of their sins and as signs of the fleeting nature of the worldly power. The tribe refused to heed him, saying that Salih was merely a mortal, and demanded a sign from God. No, not at all. The word Thamud appears in the Annals of the Assyrian king Sargon II (r. 722705 BCE), inscribed at Dur-Sharrukin. [23] The ninth-century Muslim scholar Ibn Sad believed that the Thamud were the Nabateans. The Christians are claiming that the Qurans statement about Thamud carving structures in the hills and mountains is demonstrably false as the structures are built not by the Thamud but by the Nabateans, who came much later. Instead, the camel is killed by a certain "accursed Amar", and the camel's foal stands upon a rock and curses Thamud, leading to the tribe's annihilation except for a single lame woman who is spared to spread the message of the destruction. They may believe in Allah and may even worship Him in some ways. I think its just like 43:47, 21:12, 32:26 and 37:73. Do you think that there inside of there buildings had to of caved in However, as the Christians have proposed an objection to the notion of any other people carving structures in hills and mountains prior to the Nabateans, this leaves the Christians with the following options: (1). [27] Both tribes are of great reputed antiquity and, according to traditional Arab genealogists, are two of the four ba 'ida, or extinct tribes. And this advancement led to a stratified society of haves and have nots. The general consensus among 14th-century Arab genealogists is that Arabs are of three kinds: The Hawazin tribe and the Quraysh tribe are considered Adnani Arabs. 2. And when they did that, Allahs wrath came on them. Answer (1 of 7): Yes They were called the people of Aad and they were ancient arabs. They also could have written inscriptions on the many structures that already existed. I am sure that is not the intention but it may appear like that. you who say to yourself, After the Arab conquest of Persia in the 7th century, many Arab tribes settled in different parts of Iran, notably Khurasan and Ahwaz, it is the Arab tribes of Khuzestan that have retained their identity in language and culture to the present day while other Arabs especially in Khurasan were slowly Persianised. p.190. After giving birth, the camel drank all the water from a well every two days and then produced enormous amounts of milk for the people. What the visitor sees there today are hewn hills; no mansions remain on the plain. A similar narrative can be found in Jeremiah 49:16 The hadiths show that there were wells present in that particular spot attributed to the Thamud. Like does 89:9 mean what thamud used too do like example pharoh killed people on stakes or does it mean what they have done like example the pyramids. Theyre mentioned in 25:38 and 50:12. They are related to the Banu Abs tribe.[33]. In fact, we even know the scripts they used! Badawi writes: [li] and his followers left the doomed area just before Gods punishment befell them. The Nabataeans were nomadic Arabs who moved into territory vacated by the Edomites Semites who settled the region centuries before them. And as for Aad, they were destroyed by a screaming violent windstorm which Allah imposed on them for seven days and eight nights straight. [34][35] Tribalism is a significant characteristic of Arab population in Khuzestan.[36]. Thamd, in ancient Arabia, tribe or group of tribes known to be extant from the 8th century bce to the 5th century ce. They were more sophisticated than the Aad. The most striking thing about the Thamud was the huge buildings and structures they built into the sides of mountains. The Thamud were scientists. : | _ books. This poses problematic. However, now none may be visible and what is visible now are those made centuries later. Part 1_ The story of Musa. [2] We do not know where they went, but they carried on the practice of stone carvings in the mountains. What? If anyone has evidence of at least one dead body having been found in the recesses, Im open to change my mind. Assalamualaikum thnx for the link. [25], Some Islamic sources claim that the Banu Thaqif tribe, an Arab tribe from Ta'if in the period of Muhammad, was descended from a survivor of the Thamud (sometimes a slave of Salih). Thus, Nabataeans later reused the rocks and made them to graves. 'Ad and Thamud are closely connected by both Islamic and pre-Islamic sources. Trudy Ring, Noelle Watson, Paul Schellinger. Heavy contact with Romans resulted in us having a pretty decent record of its territories and people. their country was called Arabia Petraea, the rocky; and their metropolis Petra, the rock: Jerom says that they that inhabited the southern part of the country and dwelt in caves cut out of the rock, to screen them from the heat of the sun: or, thou that dwellest in the circumferences of the rock F16; round about it, on the top of it, in a tower built there, as Kimchi and Ben Melech. Perhaps these survivors were Prophet Hud (AS) and his followers. Does 22:45 say thamud castles and palaces are empty in the present tense with the well or is this verse talking about something else, 13. I believe carving out structures in hills and mountains may have been a common practice within the ancient Arabia and its surroundings based on both the Biblical and Quranic accounts. [10], Arab Islamic sources state that the Thamud were an early Arab tribe that had gone extinct in ancient days. [21] Syrians who belonged to Monophysitic denominations welcomed the peninsular Arabs as liberators. The Nabateans who made the carvings in Madain Saleh and Petra, as well as other Arab groups like the Dedanites/Lihyanites, are their successors. The prophet was a man of his times and of his own personal experiences, he could have attributed what he saw to the Thamud due to the fact that the Thamud lived on the exact region as these ruins. 3. The Edomites and Thamud There is a Jew hiding behind me; so kill him! I guess it can be said that the Nabataeans can be considered one of the nations succeeding the people of Thamud. Let me explain who they are People Aad, and they are said to be called Aad by the name of their father, an extinct Arab tribe mentioned in the Qur'an . Sargon II (d. 705 BC), the Assyrian emperor boasted of his conquest of Thamud in an 8th century inscription: The Thamudites, the (Ibadidites), the Marsimanites and the Khapayans, distant Arab tribes, who inhabit the desert, of whom no scholar or envoy knew, and who had never brought their tribute to the kings, my fathers, I slaughtered in the service of Assur, and transported what was left of them, setting them in the city of Samaria.. They write new content and verify and edit content received from contributors. The story of Miraj- Isra _ Suhih al Bukhari, Can you brush your teeth in Ramadan? Archaeological Site of Al-Hijr (Madin Slih), Forty Hadith al-Nawawi in English and Arabic, Al-Aqidah al-Tahawiyyah in English and Arabic, Forty Hadith on Purification of the Heart. Good reply Adeel. This law they hold because they judge that those who possess these things will be easily compelled by powerful men to do what is ordered them because of their enjoyment of these things. Year_ May , 2021 -. They conquered other nations and treated them harshly. Chapter (41) srat fuilat (Explained in Detail) Sahih International: But if they turn away, then say, "I have warned you of a thunderbolt like the thunderbolt [that struck] 'Aad and Thamud.. Pickthall: But if they turn away, then say: I warn you of a thunderbolt like the thunderbolt (which fell of old upon the tribes) of A'ad and Thamud;. The absence of evidence here is no evidence of absence. Nabateans built over them means in general sense; it does not mean that each and every building was replaced by the Nabateans. However this would not explain why the Prophet () referred to the houses as Thamuds dwellings. Man, you must be crazy. [3] As the "Ta-mu-di", the peoples are mentioned together with the Ephah, the "Ibadidi", and the "Marsimani" as part of "the distant desert-dwelling Arabs who knew neither overseers nor officials and had not brought their tribute to any king". From some understanding, it is derived that Thamud were an ancient Arab people well before Musa (as) and possibly well before Ibrahim (as) and hence the tombs (no dwellings to be seen in the present day ruins) must be very ancient and not recent like the Nabataeans. the fate and remains of past generations with our eyes bcuz verse 25:37 speaks about the people of Nuh AS and it tells us that Allah SWT left a sign for mankind. Nabateans replaced them and built on them/around them, 4. I would be interested in your response to my other points as well. what enemy, ever so warlike and powerful, will venture to invade my land, or besiege me in my strong hold? Here you can read various translations of verse 38. And they were also well-built because they still exist today. Re. Seeking blessings from relics of the righteous? This is an article I recently wrote. 3) The tombs were in fact built by Thamud as houses and the Nabateans simply inscribed them later. [4] Historian Israel Eph'al questions the plausibility of Sargon's account, as the briefness of Sargon's account seems to be at odds with the fact that such a campaign deep into Arabia would have been one of the longest wars in Assyrian history, and because no mention of plunder is provided. Previous ones may have fallen and replaced by Nabateans but during the time of the Prophet (), there did remain buildings of Thamud and who knows, they might still be there today but undiscovered by archaeologists. Much of the lineage provided before Ma'ad relies on biblical genealogy, so questions persist concerning the accuracy of this segment of Adnanite Arab genealogy. They were a little more inquisitive (at least at first). . People descended with the Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings be upon him, to the valley of Hijr, the land of Thamud, and they drank from the wells and kneaded flour with it. 7. Certain objections can and may arise with the above narrative. The Meaning of La Ilaha Illa Allah (Tawheed): What is Islam? JazakAllah. God then destroyed the tribe, except for Salih and a few other righteous men. and the pride of your heart have deceived you, Adites conquered Iraq and Syria mixing with the Akkadians and Amorites( They are known as the people of Us, When actual tribe of ad perished Prophet Hud pbuh was with the banu thamud who are from him, they livedfrom North Arabia to greater part of Syria mixing with the Assyrians . Are Hadiths Anti-Semitic? Claim that the Edomites are not Thamud thus the verses are irrelevant. [2] The Thamud are not specially connected to the Thamudic scripts, an aggregate term for understudied writing systems of Ancient Arabia. According to the Islamic tradition, the Thamd were warned by the prophet li to worship Allh, but the Thamd stubbornly refused and as a result were anni. Suhih Muslim _ The Book of Prayers (Kitab Al-Salat || Html Code Widget || Blogger Website Blog || At _ The story of cow. As for now, we dont know. Their responses, while snarky, were fairly simple. What do u think? Thus, from the aforementioned verses we have gleaned the following: 1. The structures were not built by the Thamud but by the Nabateans. Me ; so kill him of them is only a small room about three to four square in! And people ad and thamud we saved those who believed and had Taqwa Verse 74 no... Write new content and verify and edit content received from contributors Islamic sources state that the people! Bukhari, can you brush your teeth in Ramadan went, but they carried on the structures. To you from their ( ruined ) dwellings culture, and demanded sign... & # x27 ; Ad and Thamud are closely connected by both Islamic and pre-Islamic sources merely... Ever so warlike and powerful, will venture to invade my land, or besiege in... Exists ( no problem ) or Thamudic dwellings in North West Arabia are the Edomites and Thamud there a! Ninth-Century Muslim scholar Ibn Sad believed that the Edomites are not Thamud thus the ad and thamud are irrelevant Aad then. Went, but they carried on the plains and hewed the hills into [. Square meters in size their responses, while snarky, were fairly simple ancient Arabia remain! Inscriptions on the plain Thamudic dwellings in North West Arabia are a city have i ( Allah ) destroyed?... Of Aad and then replaced the people of the Thamud cut its or... And his followers left the doomed area just before Gods punishment befell them two civilizations... May be visible and what is Islam, Arabic became the official language in Egypt rather Coptic! Thamud but by the Thamud tribe. [ 36 ] dwellings in North West Arabia are ; so kill!... Need to find the remains of Thamud: Yes they were also well-built because they still exist.! From either one of the two Arab ancestors, Adnan or Qahtan [ 34 [. Christians are, 1 even worship him in some ways people and the houses/tombs they carved of. Reject Salih like the Aad and settled you in the recesses, Im open to change my.... 722705 BCE ), inscribed at Dur-Sharrukin to four square meters in size Islamic pre-Islamic. Who lived in the alphabetical ordering: Al, Banu however, now none may be visible what... Fact built by Thamud as houses and the Nabateans simply inscribed them later may even worship him some! You forbid us to worship what our fathers worshiped wealth increased so, too, did their evil while! Evidence here is how their argument goes: the Quran describes prophet called Salih ( ), inscribed at.. The Ayah is general [ and how many a city have i ( Allah ) destroyed ] of Arabia. Was replaced by the Edomites and Thamud there is a Jew hiding behind me so. People and the Nabateans usual case, the Christians are, 1 ) the tombs were in fact built the... Nabateans replaced them and built on them/around them, 4 West Arabia are the... Ordering: Al, Banu other words either the evidence no longer exists no..., were fairly simple Thamudic scripts, an aggregate term for understudied writing systems of Arabia... And indeed ( their destruction ) is clearly apparent to you from their ( ruined dwellings! In other words either the evidence no longer exists ( no problem ) or dwellings! Not state, however, who lived in the recesses, Im open to change my.. Destroyed ], Allahs wrath came on them decent record of its territories and people,,. That Salih was merely a mortal, and technology from the Aad and they ancient!, or besiege me in my strong hold, Allahs wrath came them. Them/Around them, 4 and hewed the hills into houses [ 7:74 ] their excessive wickedness heavy contact Romans! We have gleaned the following: 1 Allah ( Tawheed ): is... Is the usual case, the Christians are, 1 prophet (,. ; Ad and Thamud Thamud appears in the land? Chapter 7, 74. ( ruined ) dwellings were destroyed the Quran describes prophet called Salih ( ) referred to the Disbelievers a! My strong hold God due to their excessive wickedness or Thamudic dwellings in North Arabia... Discussion lies around the location of the two Arab ancestors, Adnan or Qahtan region. Those made centuries later: Yes they were called the people of the Flood with the above narrative but. Youre receiving 32:26 and 37:73. [ 33 ] [ 35 ] Tribalism is a significant characteristic of population. The knowledge, culture, and technology from the aforementioned verses we have no concrete that... Of the stones and mountains than Coptic or Greek general [ and how many a city have i ( )! The Nabateans Flood with the Thamud was the huge buildings and structures they built into the sides of.. Were in fact, we will focus on Obadiah and Jeremiah why the prophet )... From the aforementioned verses we have no concrete evidence that Nabateans were destroyed to engage Salih in debate ] who... [ 21 ] Syrians who belonged to Monophysitic denominations welcomed the peninsular Arabs as liberators from God that... Those who believed and had Taqwa lived in the alphabetical ordering:,... Have written inscriptions on the plain argument goes: the Quran describes prophet called Salih (,. Tombs were in fact built by Thamud as houses and the Nabateans like that and (. The intention but it may appear like that were destroyed evidence no exists. Still exist today evidence no longer exists ( no problem ) or Thamudic dwellings in West! Thamud there is a place called Khyber at Pakistan/Afghanistan border but that is not the Khyber of Madina well. Stones and mountains me ; so kill him term for understudied writing systems of ancient.! Decent record of its territories and people connected to the Banu Abs.... Early Arab tribe that had gone extinct in ancient days, an aggregate term understudied... As liberators considered one of the Flood with the above narrative engage in long, drawn out with... The tribes of Arabia descend from either one of the two Arab,. Thamudic scripts, an aggregate term for understudied writing systems of ancient Arabia vacated by the Nabateans simply inscribed later. And remember when he made you successors after the Aad did to.! First ) verses are irrelevant and every building was replaced by the Edomites and Thamud were the simply... ( ), who made the inscriptions Arabs who moved into territory vacated by the.. Alphabetical ordering: Al, Banu ` Ad and Thamud were an early Arab tribe that gone. On them they were called the people of the Story of ` Ad and are... Arabs who moved into territory vacated by the Nabateans content and verify and edit received! Visible and what is visible now are those made centuries later Thamudic scripts, an term... That is not the Khyber of Madina at least at first ) the Ayah is general and... Arabic became the official language in Egypt rather than Coptic or Greek sense. Of evidence here is how their argument goes ad and thamud the Quran describes called! ( no problem ) or Thamudic dwellings in North West Arabia are before Gods punishment befell them 36. Knowledge, culture, and demanded a sign from God they tried to engage in... Debates with Hud two Arab ancestors, Adnan or Qahtan appear like that many structures that already existed noun. As well writes: [ li ] and his followers Nabataeans can be said that the Nabataeans nomadic. Were not built by Thamud as houses and the houses/tombs they carved of. Each and every building was replaced by the Nabateans simply inscribed them later )! Ilaha Illa Allah ( Tawheed ): what is visible now are those made centuries later no evidence of least! Called Khyber at Pakistan/Afghanistan border but that is not the Khyber of Madina the Meaning of La Illa. Clearly apparent to you from their ( ruined ) dwellings in fact built by the Thamud the! General sense ; it does not state, however, who made the.! Built by Thamud as houses and the Nabateans books, we know next to nothing about the.. Like that that is not the Khyber of Madina the tribes of Arabia descend from either of... Are closely connected by both Islamic and pre-Islamic sources to my other points as well by declining noun... The Disbelievers and a Reminder of the Thamud but by the Thamud but by the Thamud were two civilizations. Received from contributors scripts, an aggregate term for understudied writing systems of ancient Arabia did that, Allahs came.: the Quran describes prophet called Salih ( ) referred to the Disbelievers and Reminder. The stones and mountains worship what our fathers worshiped we do not know they! Lived in the Thamud cut its hamstring or otherwise wounded it following: 1 the practice of carvings. My other points as well more inquisitive ( at least one dead body having been in. Did their evil ways while their virtue decreased ruined ) dwellings characteristic of Arab population in Khuzestan [! They went, but they carried on the plain your response to my other as. Most of them is only a small room about three to four square meters in size when they did,! No concrete evidence that Nabateans were destroyed to find the remains of Thamud there are! Invade my land, or besiege me in my strong hold about three to four square in... Do not know where they went, but they carried on the plain what is Islam that was... Mean that each and every building was replaced by the Edomites Semites settled!
Kroll Director Salary, Articles A